1B
Ryan Howard
Ryan Howard suffered a severe injury on the final play of the season last year. This year he came back early but was still hampered by his Achilles injury. He was out of shape and unable to do his regular off season workout and it showed. Howard’s average was dismal, his K rate jumped and his defense was the worst in years. Still his presence in the lineup makes the Phillies a better team. I think Howard deserves credit for coming back from his injury and playing hurt. Season Grade: C Next Year: Back in Philly, hopefully healthy.
Ty Wigginton
Wigginton was well below his career norms in OBP, SLG and OPS. Defensively a statue would have been more effective. I was expecting more from Wigginton and I think the Phillies were also. Season Grade: C- Next Year: A toss up, I would buy him out, but, the Phils just may keep him.
2B
Chase Utley
Chase had a well interesting season. After missing half of it with his chronic knee injury he barely missed another game for the rest of the season. One of the major questions for next year is how many games can Chase play and will he be ready at the start of the season. Offensively Chase flashed decent power and a good OBP. He was however, below his career norms in OBP, SLG and OPS. Defensively Chase was excellent as usual. Season Grade: C+ Next Year: Back in Philly
Freddie Galvis
Galvis played fantastic defense and showed some progress with the bat. A season ending back injury and suspension for PEDS marred what was looking like a decent rookie campaign for Galvis. Season Grade: C- Next Year: Back in Philly
Michael Martinez
Uggg. Season Grade: F Next Year: Back in Philly, should be at Leigh Valley
SS
Jimmy Rollins
I honestly cannot think why Jimmy Rollins is criticized so much in Philly. Jimmy was just below his career norms in OBP, SLG and OPS. Yes, he pops up too much and no he is not the ideal leadoff hitter, however he continues to be one of baseball’s best hitting shortstops. To top it off he is still one of the best defensive shortstops with excellent range and a strong arm. Philly fans should consider themselves lucky he is a Philly. Season Grade: A Next Year: Back at SS
3B
Placado Polanco
Low average, no power, missed half of the season, nuf said. Season Grade: D Next Year: Somewhere else
Kevin Frandson
Frandson played well in several positions and finished the season playing with an injury that only caused him to miss a few games. Even regressing next year he should be solid. I would like to see him as the primary backup infielder with Martinez off of the roster. Season Grade: A Next Year: Back in Philly
Mike Fontenot
Did what was expected of him, easily replaceable. Season Grade: B Next Year: Already gone
C
Carlos Ruiz
You cannot say enough good things about Carlos Ruiz. He handles the pitching staff masterfully. He plays great defense. He hits for average and power. All while playing one of the most difficult positions. He would be in strong consideration for post season awards if he had played in more games. Season Grade: A Next Year: Back in Philly
Eric Kratz
A journey man minor leaguer, Kratz finally got a shot to show what he can do and did not waste it. I think he should have been the backup catcher last year. Kratz handled the pitching staff well and hit for nice power. Season Grade: A Next Year: Back in Philly
Brian Schneider
Schneider was okay when he played, which was not very often. Season Grade: D Next Year: Somewhere else.